YouTube unveils copy protection plan, spoils everyone’s fun

October 17th, 2007 by James in Tech News

GooTube

YouTube, the ever popular video upload and viewing site, has unveiled a copy protection plan which will prevent members from uploading copyrighted content without permission. The infrastructure developed requires copyright holders to provide GooTube with copies of their work so they can be compared with any copyrighted video or audio upload that infringes. Once verified, a movie will be automatically deleted. But what is really telling about it is that copyright holders will have the option to sell ads around any video clips they choose to keep available on YouTube.

It’s unclear whether the new plan will placate Hollywood Studios like Viacom which filed a $1.2 billion lawsuit forcing YouTube to pull hundreds of thousands of video clips members had posted. Google says that up to nine studios have already actively participated in successfully testing the protection plan, Walt Disney Co. and Time Warner Inc., being among them.
Viacom seems to be taking a measured wait and see attitude towards YouTube’s copy protection plan. They applaud the effort, but it’s too soon to tell if it will completely satisfy Viacom to the point of dropping their lawsuit. Other plaintiffs with similar lawsuits have slammed the plan, stating it’s completely inadequate. Because the plan requires copyright holders to provide copies of the material they want to protect, critics argue that this will only fuel piracy further, not abate it. But that’s a straw dog as perfect video copies can be made from any store bought DVD (much less the true culprits - which are inside jobs from video duplicators handling the manufacture of the DVDs in the first place).

But the bummer is that some of the best clips that made YouTube what it is today won’t be around once the plan goes live. If it ever does, that is.

Source: ABC via Gear Live

  • email to friend Email to a friend
  • Leave a comment Leave a comment
  • Share Share

Join and subscribe to our free daily digest

4 Comments on “YouTube unveils copy protection plan, spoils everyone’s fun”

Ben Althauser Says:

October 17th, 2007 at 3:52 pm

I think it’s interesting that it took so many intelligent CEOs to “catch on” to the fact that it was copyright infringement. To be insane for a moment however, it’s plausible to say that radiation from the broadcasts emanating and affecting our brain activity, and how movies psychologically affect our decisions and action is copyright infringement also. It’s beginning to get ridiculous, and in my opinion short clips or 10 minute excerpts from full movies are actually benefitting the corporations via that of free advertising. I would say a more logical approach would be to use a percentage incrementation formula - ie: for a one hour movie, you can use 7 minutes, for a 2 hour, 14, and so on. People are just to greedy.

Neagle Says:

October 17th, 2007 at 7:53 pm

The virtual world moves fast sometimes to it’s own detriment. How many screws keep trying to find ways of profiting of the free flow of knowledge and the desire to pull a profit off of others work? I respect intellectual property of others work but, if one squeezes the “water balloon” to tight it will pop.

Jeannie Says:

October 18th, 2007 at 1:35 am

I think it is a good move for you tube. There has been too much drama in this department. Hopefully it will really work and not just pull the wool temporarily over our eyes.

Gallery Gadgets Posted from Brazil (here for the GP) » Coolest Gadgets Says:

October 19th, 2007 at 9:59 am

[...] YouTube unveils copy protection plan, spoils everyone’s fun [...]

Post a Comment


You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>



New Arrivals at Hammacher Schlemmer
  • Signup because it's Tuesday

  • Add to Google Reader or Homepage
  • RSS
  • Bloglines
  • MyYahoo
  • MyMSN
  • newsgator
  • or via email
  • Coolest Reviews The latest addition to the coolest network, independant hands on reviews of all the latest gadgets and technology.
  • Game Addicts Reports on all the latest news in the gaming industry along with reviews on the latest addictive games
  • Say No To Crack A cool and funny humor site for all ages
  • Self Made Minds A blog about business and making money on the web
  • SoftSift News and reviews on the latest software releases